Edmonton vs. Calgary: The Battle of Alberta
We may be cut from the same cloth, but there's nothing wrong with a little sibling rivalry
By Emil Tiedemann
The "Battle of Alberta" has been around for as long as Alberta has been, back when they had to figure out which city would become the provincial capital and which would host the University of Alberta. Edmonton eventually came out on top in both facets, but even before that there's been a rivalry between our two cities' various sports teams dating all the way back to the 19th century.
Even today, that intrinsic rivalry between Edmonton and Calgary remains, whether it's over economic durability, athletic achievement, or simply which city has the tallest tower. It's silly, I know, but I think there can be benefits in some friendly competition. I mean, we're cut from the same cloth and we're there for each other when it comes down to it, but what's wrong with a little sibling rivalry!
Now, I understand that I am somewhat biased, considering I run a blog called "I Heart Edmonton," but I did my best to be as impartial as I possibly could, under the circumstances. Below, I came up with a number of categories that any city would be proud to brag about, and compared #YEG & #YYC by the numbers.
There is no clear "winner" here, and in fact it only confirms that our two cities not only have a lot to be proud of, but also that we're actually pretty comparable. You be the judge...
P.S. The "winner" for each of the 50 categories will be highlighted in red, unless there is a tie.
HISTORY & STATS:
Founded/
Edmonton: 1795
Calgary: 1875
Incorporated (as Town)/
Edmonton: January 9, 1892
Calgary: November 7, 1884
Incorporated (as City)/
Edmonton: October 8, 1904
Calgary: January 1, 1894
Population (City) (2016)/
Edmonton: 932,546
Calgary: 1,239,220
Population (Metro) (2016)/
Edmonton: 1,321,426
Calgary: 1,392,609
Area (Metro)/
Edmonton: 9,438 km2
Calgary: 5,110 km2
ECONOMY & GOVERNMENT:
Median Income (2016)/
Edmonton: $101,470
Calgary: $104,530
GDP (2013)/
Edmonton: $88.2 billion
Calgary: $97.9 billion
Unemployment Rates (Jan. 2018)/
Edmonton: 7.2%
Calgary: 7.6%
Lowest Taxes in Canada (2017)/
Edmonton: 46th place
Calgary: 43rd place
Best Open Data Canadian Cities (2017)/
Edmonton: 1st (98.3% score)
Calgary: 4th (69.0% score)
Best Places in Canada for Business (2016)/
Edmonton: 2nd place
Calgary: no placing (Top 25)
Tallest Building/
Edmonton: 250.8 m (Stantec Tower)
Calgary: 247 m (Brookfield Place East)
Airport Passenger Traffic (2017)/
Edmonton: 7.8 million (YEG)
Calgary: 16.27 million (YYC)
CLIMATE & LIVING STANDARDS:
World's Best Cities Ranking (2018)/
Edmonton: 60th
Calgary: 34th
Canadian Living Standards (2017)/
Edmonton: 96th
Calgary: 75th
Best Places in Canada to Retire (2017)/
Edmonton: 65th
Calgary: 63rd
Emergency Room Waiting Times (Average) (2017)/
Edmonton: 3.6 hours
Calgary: 3.0 hours
Annual Hours of Sunshine/
Edmonton: 2,299
Calgary: 2,396
Average High (Year)/
Edmonton: 9.3 Degrees Celsius
Calgary: 10.8 Degrees Celsius
Top Universities Ranking (2016/17)/
Edmonton: 4th (University of Alberta)
Calgary: 8th (University of Calgary)
Hours Per Year Spent in Traffic (2016)/
Edmonton: 17.2 hours
Calgary: 15.7 hours
Distance to Banff/
Edmonton: 413.4 km (4 hours, 8 minutes)
Calgary: 126.6 km (1 hour, 26 minutes)
Distance to Jasper/
Edmonton: 365.4 km (3 hours, 54 minutes)
Calgary: 412.5 km (4 hours, 56 minutes)
SPORTS:
Stanley Cups/
Edmonton: 5 (Oilers)
Calgary: 1 (Flames)
Grey Cups/
Edmonton: 14 (Eskimos)
Calgary: 7 (Stampeders)
Memorial Cups/
Edmonton: 3 (Oil Kings)
Calgary: 1 (Canadians)
Vanier Cups/
Edmonton: 3
Calgary: 4
U Sports University Cups/
Edmonton: 15
Calgary: 0
CJFL Championships/
Edmonton: 8
Calgary: 2
Host of Olympics/
Edmonton: 0
Calgary: 1 (1988)
Host of Commonwealth Games/
Edmonton: 1 (1978)
Calgary: 0
Stadium Seating/
Edmonton: 56,302 (Commonwealth)
Calgary: 35,400 (McMahon)
Arena Seating/
Edmonton: 18,347 (Rogers Place)
Calgary: 19,289 (Scotiabank Saddledome)
Famous NHL Team Players/
Edmonton: Wayne Gretzky, Connor McDavid, Mark Messier
Calgary: Jarome Iginla, Theoren Fleury, Lanny McDonald
ARTS & CULTURE:
Fringe Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1982
Calgary: 2001
Pride Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1980
Calgary: 1990
Folk Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1980
Calgary: 1980
Hometown Celebrities/
Edmonton: Michael J. Fox, k.d. lang, Tommy Chong
Calgary: Elisha Cuthbert, Paul Gross, Tegan & Sara
Orchestra Founding/
Edmonton: 1920
Calgary: 1910
Opera Founding/
Edmonton: 1963
Calgary: 1972
FOOD:
Top 100 Restaurants (2017)/
Edmonton: 6
Calgary: 8
Top 10 Best New Restaurants (2017)/
Edmonton: 3
Calgary: 1
Food Bank Founding/
Edmonton: 1981
Calgary: 1982
SOCIAL MEDIA:
Official City Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 198,000
Calgary: 240,000
Mayor's Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 152,000 (Don Iveson)
Calgary: 391,000 (Naheed Nenshi)
NHL Team Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 799,000 (Oilers)
Calgary: 597,000 (Flames)
Official City Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 24,500
Calgary: 36,600
Mayor's Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 25,600
Calgary: 43,000
NHL Team Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 449,000
Calgary: 283,000
By Emil Tiedemann
The "Battle of Alberta" has been around for as long as Alberta has been, back when they had to figure out which city would become the provincial capital and which would host the University of Alberta. Edmonton eventually came out on top in both facets, but even before that there's been a rivalry between our two cities' various sports teams dating all the way back to the 19th century.
The "Battle of Alberta" has been going on for more than a century now. |
Even today, that intrinsic rivalry between Edmonton and Calgary remains, whether it's over economic durability, athletic achievement, or simply which city has the tallest tower. It's silly, I know, but I think there can be benefits in some friendly competition. I mean, we're cut from the same cloth and we're there for each other when it comes down to it, but what's wrong with a little sibling rivalry!
Now, I understand that I am somewhat biased, considering I run a blog called "I Heart Edmonton," but I did my best to be as impartial as I possibly could, under the circumstances. Below, I came up with a number of categories that any city would be proud to brag about, and compared #YEG & #YYC by the numbers.
There is no clear "winner" here, and in fact it only confirms that our two cities not only have a lot to be proud of, but also that we're actually pretty comparable. You be the judge...
P.S. The "winner" for each of the 50 categories will be highlighted in red, unless there is a tie.
Edmontonians celebrating at a parade in 1920. |
HISTORY & STATS:
Founded/
Edmonton: 1795
Calgary: 1875
Incorporated (as Town)/
Edmonton: January 9, 1892
Calgary: November 7, 1884
Incorporated (as City)/
Edmonton: October 8, 1904
Calgary: January 1, 1894
Population (City) (2016)/
Edmonton: 932,546
Calgary: 1,239,220
Population (Metro) (2016)/
Edmonton: 1,321,426
Calgary: 1,392,609
Area (Metro)/
Edmonton: 9,438 km2
Calgary: 5,110 km2
The Calgary International Airport, Canada's 4th busiest airport. |
ECONOMY & GOVERNMENT:
Median Income (2016)/
Edmonton: $101,470
Calgary: $104,530
GDP (2013)/
Edmonton: $88.2 billion
Calgary: $97.9 billion
Unemployment Rates (Jan. 2018)/
Edmonton: 7.2%
Calgary: 7.6%
Lowest Taxes in Canada (2017)/
Edmonton: 46th place
Calgary: 43rd place
Best Open Data Canadian Cities (2017)/
Edmonton: 1st (98.3% score)
Calgary: 4th (69.0% score)
Best Places in Canada for Business (2016)/
Edmonton: 2nd place
Calgary: no placing (Top 25)
Tallest Building/
Edmonton: 250.8 m (Stantec Tower)
Calgary: 247 m (Brookfield Place East)
Airport Passenger Traffic (2017)/
Edmonton: 7.8 million (YEG)
Calgary: 16.27 million (YYC)
The University of Alberta in Edmonton was founded in 1908. |
CLIMATE & LIVING STANDARDS:
World's Best Cities Ranking (2018)/
Edmonton: 60th
Calgary: 34th
Canadian Living Standards (2017)/
Edmonton: 96th
Calgary: 75th
Best Places in Canada to Retire (2017)/
Edmonton: 65th
Calgary: 63rd
Emergency Room Waiting Times (Average) (2017)/
Edmonton: 3.6 hours
Calgary: 3.0 hours
Annual Hours of Sunshine/
Edmonton: 2,299
Calgary: 2,396
Average High (Year)/
Edmonton: 9.3 Degrees Celsius
Calgary: 10.8 Degrees Celsius
Top Universities Ranking (2016/17)/
Edmonton: 4th (University of Alberta)
Calgary: 8th (University of Calgary)
Hours Per Year Spent in Traffic (2016)/
Edmonton: 17.2 hours
Calgary: 15.7 hours
Distance to Banff/
Edmonton: 413.4 km (4 hours, 8 minutes)
Calgary: 126.6 km (1 hour, 26 minutes)
Distance to Jasper/
Edmonton: 365.4 km (3 hours, 54 minutes)
Calgary: 412.5 km (4 hours, 56 minutes)
The Calgary Flames won the Stanley Cup in 1989. |
SPORTS:
Stanley Cups/
Edmonton: 5 (Oilers)
Calgary: 1 (Flames)
Grey Cups/
Edmonton: 14 (Eskimos)
Calgary: 7 (Stampeders)
Memorial Cups/
Edmonton: 3 (Oil Kings)
Calgary: 1 (Canadians)
Vanier Cups/
Edmonton: 3
Calgary: 4
U Sports University Cups/
Edmonton: 15
Calgary: 0
CJFL Championships/
Edmonton: 8
Calgary: 2
Host of Olympics/
Edmonton: 0
Calgary: 1 (1988)
Host of Commonwealth Games/
Edmonton: 1 (1978)
Calgary: 0
Stadium Seating/
Edmonton: 56,302 (Commonwealth)
Calgary: 35,400 (McMahon)
Arena Seating/
Edmonton: 18,347 (Rogers Place)
Calgary: 19,289 (Scotiabank Saddledome)
Famous NHL Team Players/
Edmonton: Wayne Gretzky, Connor McDavid, Mark Messier
Calgary: Jarome Iginla, Theoren Fleury, Lanny McDonald
The Edmonton Fringe Festival is the largest and oldest in North America. |
ARTS & CULTURE:
Fringe Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1982
Calgary: 2001
Pride Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1980
Calgary: 1990
Folk Festival Founding/
Edmonton: 1980
Calgary: 1980
Hometown Celebrities/
Edmonton: Michael J. Fox, k.d. lang, Tommy Chong
Calgary: Elisha Cuthbert, Paul Gross, Tegan & Sara
Orchestra Founding/
Edmonton: 1920
Calgary: 1910
Opera Founding/
Edmonton: 1963
Calgary: 1972
Calgary's Pigeonhole Restaurant made the Top 10 of "best restaurants" in Canada in 2017. |
FOOD:
Top 100 Restaurants (2017)/
Edmonton: 6
Calgary: 8
Top 10 Best New Restaurants (2017)/
Edmonton: 3
Calgary: 1
Food Bank Founding/
Edmonton: 1981
Calgary: 1982
The Edmonton Oilers have nearly 800,000 Twitter followers...that's 13th in the entire league. |
SOCIAL MEDIA:
Official City Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 198,000
Calgary: 240,000
Mayor's Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 152,000 (Don Iveson)
Calgary: 391,000 (Naheed Nenshi)
NHL Team Twitter Followers/
Edmonton: 799,000 (Oilers)
Calgary: 597,000 (Flames)
Official City Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 24,500
Calgary: 36,600
Mayor's Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 25,600
Calgary: 43,000
NHL Team Instagram Followers/
Edmonton: 449,000
Calgary: 283,000
Comments
Post a Comment